Date: Saturday
September 26 to Friday October 2, 2026
Anglers: Cathy
Needleman and Jan Howard
Boat and Crew: Joe
Diorio Guide and owner; boat fished was a Reef Runner.
Captains: Carter for day 1; Joe and Andrew for day 2 and
Snacks for day 3.
Trip: One
week travel to New Haven, Connecticut with Three days fishing for striped bass
(commonly referred to as stripers.)
Catch: Day
1 we caught approximately 13 stripers up to 40 pounds; Day 2 Cathy caught at
least 6 large stripers with one weighing 42 to 48 pounds; and I caught a few
smaller fish; Day 3 we were skunked.
Trip Details: Cathy
and I met at LAX for a 6 am flight to Connecticut through Atlanta. Our flight was uneventful and arrived on time
at Bradley International Airport, CT. We
picked up a rental car and drove an hour and a half, in the dark and pouring
rain of a nor’easter, arriving at our rental unit in New Haven around 9:30 pm. The electronic door lock was uncooperative,
requiring the owner to come out in the dark and rain to let us in. The accommodations were comfortable and
included two bedrooms, living room with big screen TV, study, one bath and a
full kitchen.
We were very excited especially Cathy. Catching stripers have been on her bucket
list for quite some time. Last year we traveled
to Nashville with the hope of catching stripers but a storm came through just
before our arrival loading the rivers with logs and muddy water. Our guide felt it was too dangerous to take
two old ladies out on a raging river to catch stripers so he took us to a calm
lake to catch 12 inch hybrids.
We unpacked then headed out looking for something open
for dinner. The storm caused restaurants
to close early due to power outages. We
managed to grab a Little Caesar’s pizza and purchase milk, water and cereal at
Sam’s convenience store a block away from our rental unit. Our unit was on the ground floor and there was
another unit above us. We finished the
day unpacking and settling into our home for the week.
Sunday we did a little shopping but spent most the day
watching movies while waiting out the storm. Our guide phoned to say we had to
cancel fishing on Monday due to the storm and rescheduled that day’s fishing
for Thursday. We had a nice dinner at
Waterfront Café next to the landing then went back to our rental to watch another
movie. Around 9 pm, the storm knocked
out all our power. Thank heaven our phones have a flashlight built in because
we had no idea where and what furniture we might trip over. All we could do was go to sleep. At 1:30 in the morning, all the lights went
on when the power came on. So much for a
good night’s sleep.

Monday arrived with another set of inconveniences. During the day, furniture was moved out of
the unit above us making plenty of noise.
The owner sold the house that our rental unit was in and the new owner decided
to move in before the end of our trip. Not
only did the new owner move in but the owner has two children around 3 and 5
years of age. The kids ran back and
forth across the floor above us all day. The highlight of the day was a spectacular
dinner at the Oyster Café in Mystic. I
had a delicious seared tuna with amazing flavors which rivaled dishes I’ve had at
3-star Michelin restaurants in France.
Tuesday morning at 6 am we met Carter at Thames Marina
and boarded the Reef Runner, a 28 foot center console skiff. I sat on the back deck and Cathy sat next to
the captain for the 30-minute ride to the fishing grounds. The weather was overcast and cool but the
waters were calm. Carter set us up with 30-pound,
2-foot fluoro leaders with a circle hook tied on and baited with a live eel. Carter had to change the spinners to right
hand reel for both of us. Carter told us
where to cast and said to slowly reel the eel back in then repeat until a fish
grabs it. Carter would cast and retrieve
a top water plug which the stripers loved.
Sometimes he hooked a fish and other times the fish followed the plug in
so we could hook them.
It wasn’t long before both Cathy and I hooked a
fish.
I found it difficult to pull on
these fish as the rod was quite thin and the bail on the reel hit my knuckles
each time I turned the handle.
The fish
pulled hard.
They would take a long run
then a couple shorter ones sometimes changing from right to left before the
captain could leader the fish and unhook it.
Carter set the fish in our laps for a photo then released it back into
the water.
You can keep one fish a day,
however we released everything.
We
fished until noon managing around 13 fish including another double hook up as
our last fish of the day.
The new owners apparently finished moving in while we
were fishing. The toddlers were in full
out running mode when we got back. We
cleaned up and went to dinner expecting the kids to be asleep when we
returned. We were wrong. We could barely hear our movie due to the
pounding feet on our ceiling. Cathy
finally called the owner at 10 pm and asked her to ask the new owners to quiet
down the kids. That helped some,
however, I suspect one of the kids was ADHD and that one was still walking
around at 3 am.
Wednesday we met Joe and Andrew at the landing at 5
am. Another 30 minute trip to the fishing
area. Not much current this day. Slower fishing. I was tired and sore so I let Andrew do most
my casting reserving my strength for pulling on fish. Fish didn’t bite until 7 am. The bite was slower but the fish were
generally larger. I landed 1 big
striper, 2 medium and 1 small fish. Cathy was on fire though. She landed at least 6 large stripers including
a 42 to 48 pounder. We fished until
noon. What a great experience. These fish are beautiful and really put up a
fight. I wish we had something like this
to catch just 30 minutes from land.
Joe said Snacks would meet us at 11:30 Thursday morning
for our last day of fishing. We thanked and
said goodbye to Joe and Andrew. After
cleaning up, we went to dinner at Daniel Parker’s then finished the evening
with another movie.
Thursday morning we went to the Broken Yolk Café for
breakfast. The restaurant is run by Dee
who not only runs the restaurant, cooks the meals but is entertaining as well. She greeted us by telling us to select our
coffee mug from among a couple dozen different types. The walls inside are covered with a variety of
memorabilia to entertain us when Dee was busy with other guests. The food was great and the experience worth
the detour.
We met Snacks at 11:30 for our final day of fishing. The weather was beautiful – sunny, calm winds
and no current. Captain Snacks covered
much water trying spot after spot without a single bite. Snacks said the morning had been great with many larger fish biting,
however, the afternoon was quite different.
We all understand when this occurs.
Snacks was more upset than we were that he couldn’t put us on biting
fish. We called it a day around 3:30.
We went back to the Waterfront Café for dinner then
packed up for our flight home the next day.
Much thanks goes to Joe and his captains for helping us cross
striper fishing off Cathy’s bucket list in spectacular fashion. Joe was very professional and knowledgeable about
striper fishing and taught his captains well too. We also appreciate all Joe’s restaurant recommendations. All were delicious and even entertaining.
I love being with Cathy when she accomplishes one of her
goals. Thanks Cathy for bringing me
along.